Thursday, November 7, 2013

Final Research and Conclusion

                This topic of vaccinations has been a revolution of sorts to me; not in that I've changed my opinion of vaccines being important, but in that I’m not quite so judgmental of those that choose not to vaccinate.  As I continued researching my topic, I was finally able to find an article that I felt brought up some valid points for the argument against vaccines.  Until this point, I was unable to find anything from a medical professional or reliable source; when I came across the article Hidden in Plain Sight: Vaccines as a Major Risk Factor for Chronic Disease written by Richard Moskowitz, M.D., I was truly excited to see some proof of the other side.  This article gave interesting information on some chronic diseases; some of its main points being the reasons that he felt these issues were often overlooked as being caused by the vaccines themselves.  Moskowitz believed that reasons such as: time lapses after the vaccines, they may worsen issues that already exist, they may be working with other disease-promoting factors and they “mainly represent non-specific effects of the vaccination process itself, rather than specific effects of the specific vaccines.” (Moskowitz, 112)  Although Moskowitz makes some interesting points within the examples he gives in his article, I feel that his examples so rarely occur that they cannot apply to the general population.  Freak occurrences happen within medicine all the time; not everyone is going to respond to all medications or treatments the same.  To me, Moskowitz’s just proves my previous statement about the importance of parent’s doing proper research before vaccinating; for example, if you have a history of other disorders or allergies within your family, it is crucial to properly research the vaccines.  Not all children can receive all vaccines, it’s important for parents to know if and why their children cannot. 
                This whole article led me to wonder, how many parents actually don’t vaccinate their children?  I decided to put this question to the test by asking my Facebook family.  My interest in the controversy of vaccinations first came to my attention from posts and statuses I saw on Facebook, so what better place to ask.  I posed the question of a simple Yes or No answer to whether or not people vaccinated their children.  I made a point to state that I wanted only yes or no answers; I didn't want any opinions voiced here.  I did however encourage anyone that had a strong opinion one way or the other to personal message me.  Through my survey thus far, I have found that only 2 in 50 families have not vaccinated their children.  So, this brought a new question to mind for me; does it really matter if so few people choose not to vaccinate?

                Finding an answer to my new question didn't take too much searching.  I came across an interesting concept called “Herd Immunity.”  Herd immunity is the idea that by vaccinating, you not only protect yourself from the disease, but the community as a whole.  William Schaffner, M.D., of the department of preventative medicine at Vanderbilt University explained that “unvaccinated people are protected because they are surrounded by people who are immune, so it’s harder for the bad bug to find unprotected individuals.”(Schaffner, 6)  Although this explains why many people who are unvaccinated may still remain healthy, it’s important to point out that it is because so many others are vaccinated that it is possible for the bacteria or viruses to die out before finding a viable source to feed off.  Dr. Schaffner also goes on to point out that the immune system can handle a lot, so by getting several doses of vaccines at the same time is barely a challenge to our immune system. 

                In conclusion, my research brought me to the same opinion I initially began with; that vaccines are a crucial part of our society’s ongoing health.  I feel more confident going forward in sharing my beliefs as well as am more open to hearing others opinions on the opposition.  When I initially approached this topic, I first wanted to find out if there was any proof that vaccines caused the conditions and disorders that they were accused of; I was unable to find any true substantial evidence supporting any of these claims.  I did however learn that conditions and issues that may possibly arise following vaccinations are often times associated with already occurring conditions.  This has made me realize the absolute importance of parents doing proper research before vaccinating their children and being well informed.  I've also come to the conclusion that although I’m not supportive of not vaccinating for any other reason besides medical ones, at least through herd immunity we are more protected because of those that do get vaccinated.  I think this will continue to be a hot button topic and look forward to seeing what new information arises on it.

Works Cited

Hock, Kathryn.  “Do you Vaccinate?”  Survey.  Facebook.com. Publisher, 7, November 2013.  Web.  7 Nov.  2013.

Moskowitz, Richard.  “Hidden in Plain Sight: Vaccines as a Major Risk Factor for Chronic Disease.”  American Journal of Homeopathic Medicine  106.3 (2013): 107-119.  Consumer Health Complete.  Web.   7 Nov. 2013.


Schaffner, William.  “Herd Immunity.”  Consumer Reports on Health 23.12 (2011): 6.  Consumer Health Complete.  Web.  7 Nov. 2013.

6 comments:

  1. My daughter got her 2-month vaccinations yesterday, so this topic has been on my mind the past two days! I'm glad that you found a credible article to back up the opposition, and have a good response to it. I also liked your point about herd immunity. Although, as I was at the doctor's office yesterday, our nurse practitioner told me that everyone in the family should have the TDaP vaccine if they're vaccine isn't up to date because Pertussis is going around. They've seen a couple of cases of it already in their office, and it's a pediatric office! That scares me because my husband was vaccinated as a child, but hasn't had the TDaP vaccine for several years. He works with the public, and so he's still at risk for getting pertussis, and can bring it home to my daughter who hasn't had all of her vaccines yet.

    On the flip side, my daughter was miserable yesterday, and I was really worried. So, I can see where parents are coming from in being a little suspect of vaccines. It's a smart move in your argument to encourage parents to do their own research ultimately, even though you'll be making a strong case against not vaccinating.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I really like how you found that article that explains the other side but to me as a parent who has a child with an auto immune deficiency disorder I am still so strong opinioned on getting shots. I do agree that a whole community is a lot safer and healthier when more people get the vaccines that are required but what if you have a whole community that gets sick easier? That one person can do so much damage just by coughing on that one group of people. I agree it really stinks those few days after your child get their shots, but to me those few days are way better than spending a week in a hospital seeing your child hooked up to oxygen and a feeding tube because somebody didn’t get their vaccines and got your child sick. I guess I am just so strong about this because that was me with my son. We went to my older son’s school and as everyone knows whooping cough is going around and my baby got it. We were hospitalized because he got the illness. If every child had been vaccinated maybe my son wouldn’t have gotten it. I may be the crazy mother but if you don’t have the flu shot, don’t even think for one second you will be coming in my house during the flu season. ( Thank goodness we have family and friends who know about my sons condition)

    ReplyDelete
  3. Katy,
    It's interesting to see how your view on this topic has changed over the course of your research. I know a lot of parents who do not believe or want to give their children vaccinations. Prior to reading your research I thought that getting vaccinations aren't always the best option. I thought there were more studies proving that vaccinations could lead to other illnesses or disabilities. I personally don't get a flu shot at all. I used to get them every year, and after my flu shot I was constantly getting sick. I am also deadly afraid of needles, so that might be why I don't keep up with my vaccines. I think your research is creible and actually makes me rethink vaccines. Looking over all your posts, you have really put a lot of work into your research and findings. I think if you're able to use the statistics and other information you found you're going to have a really solid paper. Great job!
    Katie

    ReplyDelete
  4. Katy,
    I agree it is up to the parents of children getting vaccinated, and anyone in general who is going to get vaccinated, to fully research the vaccines and ensure that they consult their doctor to monitor for reactions. I also think you prove your point quite well when you explain about freak occurrences and how not everyone is going to respond to the vaccines the same. I know I had my first flu vaccination this year in October, and it made my arm super sore, but what I remember most is on the consent sheet you sign it states that if you are allergic to chicken feathers you might have a reaction to the vaccine, which I thought was very odd. Great post!
    Shayna

    ReplyDelete
  5. Your research is good as it looks at both sides of the argument, and shows that not all people believe that vaccination is the right way to go. I personally have been getting shots my whole life, mostly due to school regulations,and although sometimes they make you feel slightly sick, i do hope they help me in the long run. It would be interesting to see what percentage of all American children go without vaccination, and if there are certain places where they do not regulate what you must get. So far all your research seems very credible, and from good sources. Keep up the good work.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I appreciated the fact that you spent time trying to be open and came to understand why some people may choose not to vaccinate their children. I have seven children and all of them were vaccinated but not always on time. Some times it seemed they did better if we waited and started the vaccinations when they were older. In fact their doctor did not start them until they were I think six months old for the older children. When my youngest started his vaccinations the doctor gave more shots at lower doses. He said that young children had fewer problems with the reactions that way and there was less chance of any major reactions.

    ReplyDelete